ICASA FILES ANSWERING AFFIDAVIT IN THIRD CELLPHONE COURT CASE
The Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (ICASA) has filed its affidavit in the
third cell phone court case. The affidavit is a response to NextCom's court application for an order setting aside the recommendation on the awarding of the third cell licence to Cell C made by the South African Telecommunications Regulatory Authority (SATRA) to the Minister of Communications.
May 2004 Search For More
Johannesburg - 24 JANUARY 2001
SATRA recommended to the Minister of Communications, Dr Ivy Matsepe-Casaburri, on 30 June 2000 that the licence be awarded to Cell C. On the following day, SATRA and the former Independent Broadcasting Authority (IBA) were dissolved and replaced by ICASA. In terms of the applicable legislation, ICASA is the legal successor to SATRA and the IBA and any ruling given by SATRA or the IBA before the establishment of ICASA is deemed to be a ruling made by ICASA.
In terms of the Telecommunications Act, the final decision in respect of the awarding of the third cellular licence rests in the hands of the Minister of Communications. Shortly after SATRA had made its recommendation, NextCom (one of the applicants) applied for and obtained an interdict from the Pretoria High Court, prohibiting the Minister from awarding the licence pending the outcome of NextCom's application for a judicial review of the licensing process conducted by SATRA.
In an effort to have SATRA's recommendation declared invalid, NextCom alleges that SATRA's adjudication of the licence applications was characterised by a number of procedural irregularities. NextCom does not, however, question the substantive grounds on which SATRA recommended that the licence be awarded to Cell C.
In its affidavit, which was filed with the Registrar of the Pretoria High Court on Friday 19 January 2001, ICASA asks the Court to make a finding that SATRA did not commit any reviewable irregularity in considering the licence applications. Nevertheless, ICASA states that it actively opposes only two aspects of NextCom's
review application. More particularly, ICASA opposes NextCom's application to the
extent that NextCom alleges that ICASA's predecessor, SATRA, acted in bad faith in relation to the licensing process. (In essence, NextCom alleges that SATRA decided, early in the licensing process, to recommend that the licence be awarded to Cell C and that, subsequently, SATRA acted with the "improper motive" of ensuring that nothing should interfere with that decision.) ICASA also opposes NextCom's application to the extent that NextCom seeks an order directing ICASA to pay the costs of the High Court proceedings.
As far as the remainder of NextCom's application is concerned, ICASA states, in its affidavit, that it will abide by the High Court's decision. In the affidavit the Authority has outlined factual information relating to the charges in order to assist the Court in making its determination.
Although ICASA's active participation in the court proceedings will be limited, ICASA has, in its affidavit, provided a lengthy factual exposition of the procedure that was adopted in considering the applications for the licence. The purpose of doing so is to enable the presiding judge to determine whether or not the allegations made in NextCom's court application are justifiable and whether any grounds exist for setting aside SATRA's recommendation. ICASA asks the Court to direct that NextCom must pay the legal costs incurred by ICASA in filing affidavits to put the correct facts before the Court.
ICASA's decision to adopt the approach set out above was motivated principally by the belief that it is in the best interests of the telecommunications industry that the matter be brought to finality as soon as possible. In this context, ICASA's decision was motivated by a desire to facilitate the expeditious conclusion of the court case.
It is hoped that the hearing will take place during February or March 2001.
South African Mobile & Telecoms News
Vodacom South Africa Trials 3G WCDMA Services
Vodacom South Africa Boosts Profits
Vodacom SA reaches 10m users
Cell C South Africa signs up 3 million GSM subscribers
South African SMS & Voice Traffic Jumps Over festive Season
Vodacom South Africa in record December 2003 signups
MTN Uganda gets Protek's integrated OSS
Namibian MTC GSM network orders Prepaid IN platform
Nigerian M-Tel launches new tariffs
African GSM Operators Create Mobile Phone EIR Blacklist
Nigerian M-Tel network orders Pre Paid platform
Lawsuit over GSM network seizure in Cote d'Ivoire
Somalia GSM Network gets per-second billing
MobiMap Location Based Services Now in South Africa
Nigerian GSM network orders interWave mobile base stations
South African Cell C GSM Network orders network software
Vodacom declares impressive half year results
Wataniya wins Algerian GSM license
Nigerian M-Tel network orders Pre Paid platform
Nortel wins Angolan CDMA contract
Vodacom Africa first outbound prepaid roaming service to Namibia
Vodafone to invest in Vodacom Nigeria
Gabon Telecom Selects Hughes Satellite to Connect Gabon Railways
Vodacom Africa first outbound prepaid roaming service
New SA Cellphone Tariffs
SIM Swap Deal Gives 1800Mhz to SA Operators
Telkom SA and MTN SA drop fixed to mobile call charges
Vodacom reaches 8 million subscribers
YDT and Nokia expand Make a Connection to North-West and Limpopo Provinces
Telkom to be listed in New York, Johannesburg
Vodacom launches GPRS'
MTN Nigeria Says Its OK
MCell Pulls Out Of SA Fixed Operator Bid
GSM Jamming Debate Heats Up
SA Bugging bill gets OK'd
Telkom launches commercial trial of ADSL in Gauteng
Lose Your Cellphone In South Africa And Spend 20 years in jail?
SABS Warns Of Charger Hazards
SA's Three GSM Operators Face Probe
MTN Launches GPRS & Announces Data Tariffs
Ericsson clinches Lesotho mobile network contract
MTN SA Goes Live With Free GPRS Trial
Proposals invited for M-Cell stake
Vodacom, SignalSoft, Compaq in wireless location-based services
Vodacom Selects Convergys' Geneva to Bill All Future Services
SA's Cell C Launches November 17 2001
South Africa new telecoms bill compromise reached
South Africa to amend telecoms policy - again
Siemens awarded Cell C Network Contract worth US$221m
Nextcom officially withdraws challenge to Cell C
MCell's Airborn And ICQ in deal on SMS
South Africa to open bidding for M-Cell stake
Vodacom reaches 5million users
Man arrested for SMS bomb threat to bank
Cell C Says It Will Roll Out Network By 4Q01
ICASA files its affidavit in the third license court case
South Africans Make 100m Call on New Years Day
CWU opposes Telkom privatisation
MTN Installs Tunnel Links
South African Information
:: Latest mobile statistics in South Africa (more...)
:: Vodacom South Africa - tariffs, specs, services
:: MTN South Africa - tariffs, specs, services
:: Cell C - tariffs, specs, services
:: SATRA/ICASA the regulatory body
:: Third South African Cellular License Story
:: Private Mobile Radio (PMR) Networks
:: Packet Radio Data Networks
:: Mobile Satellite Service License Holders
:: Telkom SA Tariffs To And From Mobiles
:: Cellular-related Web Sites In South & Southern Africa
The Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (ICASA) has filed its affidavit in the third cell phone court case.
The affidavit is a response to NextCom's court application for an order setting aside the recommendation on the awarding of the third cell licence to Cell C made by the South African Telecommunications Regulatory Authority (SATRA) to the Minister of Communications.
Search For More Info