BERLIN, Jan
23 2001
A German study released Monday said there was a link between cancer of the
inner eye and the use of cell phones, but critics said the finding was
based on flawed research techniques.
Andreas Stang, one of the study's authors from the
Essen University Clinic, said 118 patients with a type of eye cancer
called uveal melanoma had used cellular phones and other equipment
deploying radio waves more often than 475 healthy patients.
Scientists have disagreed whether there is a link
between cancer and cell phone usage. Studies, many funded by the wireless
industry, have given conflicting results. The concern over mobile phones
stems from the fact that when used, they emit low levels of radio
frequency energy or radiation which at high levels can cause biological
damage, according to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (news - web
sites). The effects of low levels of such radiation, however, is still a
matter of research.
Michael Foerster of Berlin's Free University
expressed doubts about the results of the University of Essen study.
``The problem with the study is that it did not
measure how much radiation the studied people had,'' he said. ``Without
such a detailed energetic study, such results are biostatistical
garbage.''
Uveal melanoma is quite rare and only impacts a few
people in 100,000, and the public should not be especially worried about
it, Stang said.